Thursday, March 30, 2006

Who wants to be a......DOCTOR?

'Who wants to be a millionaire?' was one of the famous TV show in m'sia, and also in many other countries in the world. Similarly, I actually noticed that there is an increasing trend in the amount of prospective undergrads who are really 'interested' to read medicine. Perhaps, there will soon be a new TV game show entitled 'Who wants to be a medical doctor?'. Have you ever wondered why such a phenomenon can occur?

Most of the 'prospective medical students' always claim that they wanna read medicine bcos: 1st, medicine really interests them; 2nd, they really wanna treat the patients; 3rd, they wud like to save lives. Most of you might think, well, all these are very valid reasons. I might agree with you. However, are all these reasons that actually aspire all the students to apply for the course? Well, personally, i dun think so.

As we know, most of the time, it is extremely hard to be enrolled as a medical student (this might not be true in certain unis). Bsides fulfilling the academic requirements, one needs to impress the interviewers and convince them that it is worthwhile to permit him/her to study medicine in their uni. Undoubtedly, most medical students have very brilliant academic performance. However, do they perform equally good in terms of their personalities? Do they really know what makes a GOOD DOCTOR?

Some ppl study medicine bcos this is wat their parents want?
Some ppl study medicine bcos this career guarantees them a good income in the future?
Some ppl study medicine bcos of the title 'Dr.' , which can let them enjoy a high social status?
Some ppl study medicine bcos they perform relatively better than others and this is the only course that can show their real abilities?

So, what do u think?

Sorry...I cant provide you an ans now coz i m confused. I m confused not bcoz i dunnoe y i wanna b a doctor (Of coz i know), but i m confused whether these are good reasons for a person to fight for a place in medical schs.

Smart docs are always good docs?

A doctor is given the title 'Dr.' is bcoz of what they can actually contribute to the patients and medical field. However, if a doctor always think about his or her best interest b4 consider about wat the patients really need, i think it is shameful to hold the title.

As a 1st yr medical student, and with my extremely limited knowledge in medical field, this is all that I can comment right now. The comments might be very judgemental and are not neccessarily always true, however, they are all my sincere comments. And of coz, i have met many good doctors and medical students in my life.

After all, i still want to be a good doctor.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

im sure you will be one!!

Sin Hong said...

不是每个医生都是志在救人;就像不是每个病人都想要痊愈。(见gery's anatomy 或干脆自己到医院去看看)世界上有各种各样的病人,自然也就需要各种各样的医生。如果所有医生都只会救人的话,那医院也太无趣了点。

再且,医生也不过是份职业。如果我们认同别人就业是为了赚钱,为什么医生爱财却须要遮遮掩掩呢?拜金和医德并非完全不相容。有的人仍需要偿还医药系的教育债,更多人偿还的是父母的期待。


“不问一个人的过去,只看他的将来。”


food for thought
你认为读了医学系不当医生的人是在浪费社会资源吗?

Wei Kang 小康 said...

Hm..i agree with your viewpoint. Indeed, income is important to you, me as well as every1 in the world.

"为什么医生爱财却须要遮遮掩掩呢?" This is true. Y cant those ppl, who study medicine just bcoz they wanna earn more, tell the interviewers exactly what they want during the interview? Y muz they say that they wanna save patients if they think $ is more important?

Haha...sorry for being a bit straightforward. I have no intention to argue with any1 about this topic. I just stated what is in my mind.

Imagine if a person who really has the interest to study medicine but was rejected by the uni while the other person who doesnt really wanna b a doc has got the offer instead. 5 yrs later, the person graduated dy but he doesnt 1 2 b a doc. It is true that he can still contribute to the society, but if he doesnt 1 to b a doc, y study medicine?

Wei Kang 小康 said...

oh ya sin hong...forgot to thank you for ur comment...hehe..paiseh..

Sin Hong said...

consider these cases:
a mature student of 50y/o was accepted to mad sch. after graduating, he can at most serve for 10 years.

a dentistry student come to study medicine bcuz he need a BMBS degree to perform surgery in spore.

鲁迅graduated as a qualified doc and he decided to become a writer. “治好了穷人,他们继续受资本家欺压;唯有通过教育民众,才能拯救穷人”
he eventually became the greatest writer of the era.

more... dr.mahathir...dr.lim kim yik...dr.chua...

yes we have limited resources for med edu... so have these ppl deprive of other more eligible students to study medicine?

dun mean to argue.. there is no right or wrong... jz like ethics... just that we have to broaden our mind when considering things...

relevancy to a doc
how can u decide between two worthy patients? can we reject somebody's right to medical care because of his lifestyle problem?

Wei Kang 小康 said...

中国前国家主席邓小平曾说过:“不管是黑猫还是白猫,只要会捉老鼠的就是好猫。”

伟康想说的是:“不管是唯利是图还是奋不顾身,只要他肯医人,就称得上是医生;要是他见死不救,纵使医术再高明,他也不算是一位医生。”